During mechanical thrombectomy in the anterior cerebral circulation, thrombus embolization resulting in Willisian collateral failure may lead to critical stroke outcomes due to a shutdown of leptomeningeal collaterals. We hypothesized that the outcomes of dynamic Willisian collateral failure (DWF), induced during mechanical thrombectomy, would be associated with grave outcomes. We evaluated this hypothesis in consecutive patients, between January 2011 and May 2016, who underwent mechanical thrombectomy for anterior circulation occlusions, with an onset-to-puncture of 24 h. Patients with initial Willisian collateral failure (IWF) were identified first, with remaining patients classified into the DWF and Willisian collateral sparing (WCS) groups. Comparative and multivariable analyses were performed to predict grave outcomes (3-month modified Rankin Scale score of 5-6). Among 567 patients, 37 were in the IWF group, 38 in the DWF group, and 492 in the WCS group. Compared to the WCS and DWF groups, the IWF group had a higher baseline National Institute of Health Stroke Scale score and lower Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score. The prevalence of grave outcomes was similarly high in the IWF (48.6%) and DWF (47.4%) groups, but lower in the WCS group (22.0%; p < 0.001). IWF and DWF were independent risk factors for a grave outcome.